I mean my money is on Roosevelt getting into the top three but I feel like people are forgetting how many of our presidents have fought in battle.
Washington, John Adams the first, and Monroe were Revolutionary soldiers. Pierce was fucking terrible (literally he’s down there with Trump) but he was an officer in several key battles in the Mexican-American War. Buchanan was a private in the War of 1812, while Tyler was a captain. Andrew Johnson was a brigadier in the Civil War, Fillmore was an officer, and Hayes and Garfield were generals, while Grant was THE general. (Arthur was also a brigadier, but his duties were non-combatant related.) Benjamin Harrison was so good at his job he received multiple promotions, and the war was only four years long, so that’s really saying something. And while McKinley was breveted, he did serve. Those don’t even get into the famed trenches of WWI, where Truman held several commands as a colonel. Eisenhower fought in both world wars and was so highly decorated for meritorious service that his medals have their own Wikipedia article, and I hate saying this as much as you hate hearing it, but Reagan was in WWII too, as were Ford and Nixon. Beyond that we get far more into the kind of long-range warfare that didn’t involve much Hunger Games close-quarters-style combat, but the field is pretty crowded before we ever get there.
William Henry Harrison was a soldier for thirty-three years, and Taylor for an astonishing FORTY-ONE. Teddy was great, and I believe also did military service (I’d frankly be a bit stunned if he didn’t), but the field might be a lot closer than you think. My bets are split between Buchanan and Taylor, who was the one still in active service closest to his death.
Now in terms of who would go down first, I regret to say there’s not a doubt in my mind it would be Jimmy Carter, who does not deserve that fate. He’d try to mediate between everyone else to convince them diplomacy and working together would be best, and it’d end in him getting slaughtered because the man doesn’t have an asshole bone in his body. (I Love Jimmy Carter And You Should Too.) The #2 to go would be Dubya, who bought his way out of Vietnam, isn’t too bright, and also doesn’t know when to shut the fuck up and not stick his nose in things.
I actually think Trump wouldn’t be in the first ten to go, but not for the reasons you might think. It wouldn’t be savvy, but rather the absolute lack of it, that would “save” him, and when he died he’d WISH Abe had put an axe through his head. He’d be ignored while he sat there bloviating because other actual threats would be more present, and after that he’d be too lazy and unlikeable to form any alliances. He’d probably die of dehydration and exposure still sitting on his metal plate, bitching about how the gamemakers didn’t provide nukes.
My picks for bottom five: Carter and Dubya go first, followed by Cleveland, Bush I, and Pierce. If we assume “youthful, refreshed bodies” means everyone gets back the bodies they had at age 25, I’m afraid FDR would actually go before Pierce; he’s smart enough to get the fuck out of dodge and away from the cornucopia as fast as his chair will take him, but I don’t think it would take long for him to have to abandon the chair and go on foot (a thing he was very slow and unsteady at), or, failing that, the gamekeepers would quietly off him to avoid the taint of “he killed a guy in a wheelchair” for the victor.
Top five: Teddy, Lincoln, Buchanan, Taylor, and either Obama or Benjamin Harrison.